Web Exclusive: "Love Actually" at the center of "Christmas Class - KYTX CBS 19 Tyler Longview News Weather Sports

Web Exclusive: "Love Actually" at the center of "Christmas Classic" debate

Posted: Updated:
  • CBS19.tv Web ExclusivesMore>>

  • Moms-to-be learn how to be Fit for Two

    Moms-to-be learn how to be Fit for Two

    Thursday, July 31 2014 11:54 PM EDT2014-08-01 03:54:43 GMT
    Exercising during pregnancy may have more benefits than you realize. Research finds it can make labor and delivery easier on your body. There are also benefits for baby. As little as 20 minutes of moderate exercise, three times per week enhances the newborn child's brain development.  In this week's Fit City, find out how ETMC is trying to create strong moms and healthy babies with one of its programs. More >>
    Exercising during pregnancy may have more benefits than you realize. Research finds it can make labor and delivery easier on your body. There are also benefits for baby. As little as 20 minutes of moderate exercise, three times per week enhances the newborn child's brain development.  In this week's Fit City, find out how ETMC is trying to create strong moms and healthy babies with one of its programs. More >>
  • Web Exclusive: Rob Lowe is getting "sharky" for a TV network

    Web Exclusive: Rob Lowe is getting "sharky" for a TV network

    Thursday, July 31 2014 9:45 AM EDT2014-07-31 13:45:11 GMT
    Actor Rob Lowe is lending his comedic talents to the Discovery channel.  In a new promo for Shark Week he throws up chum while riding two sharks.More >>
    Actor Rob Lowe is lending his comedic talents to the Discovery channel.  In a new promo for Shark Week he throws up chum while riding two sharks.More >>
  • Web Exclusive: Company cancels class to nix Southern accents, y'all, after complaints

    Web Exclusive: Company cancels class to nix Southern accents, y'all, after complaints

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 12:00 PM EDT2014-07-30 16:00:17 GMT
    We live in the South, so some of us may have a Southern accent, but would you consider saying "goodbye" to "howdy, y'all"?
    The Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee was going to offer a speech class for its workers next month to do just that, until it got canceled.
    More >>
    We live in the South, so some of us may have a Southern accent, but would you consider saying "goodbye" to "howdy, y'all"?
    The Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee was going to offer a speech class for its workers next month to do just that, until it got canceled.
    More >>

(CNN) - What does it take for a Christmas Movie to be considered "a classic?"  Apparently that's a matter of some debate... heated debate as evidenced by the recent online furor over the 2003 film Love Actually.

'Tis the season of classic holiday movies starting, of course, with It's A Wonderful Life, Miracle on 34th Street and in the 60's a couple TV specials were added to the cannon, How the Grinch Stole Christmas and a Charlie Brown Christmas.

There's now, a slightly newer batch of movies are starting to crowd in on the family favorites. Does Will Ferrell's Elf deserve a place on the DVR?  Hmmm. Probably not, but make no mistake, the most heated debate about Christmas movies centers around the film Love Actually.

Does it deserve to be considered a new Christmas classic?

"No," says film critic Chris Orr.

"A classic holiday movie has to have someone who is changed by the spirit of Christmas in some fashion," says Chris Orr.

Yes, says associate editor, Emma Green.

"The strength of Love Actually though, which is a more recent classic is that to me it feels more personal. it feels like something I can see in my real life potentially, hopefully, and something that feels fresh," says Emma Green.

Orr and Green write for The Atlantic.  Earlier this month, they published dueling articles, turning the film LLove Actually into a battlefield.

"Basically every one of our coworkers got up from their cubes, stopped what they were doing and surrounded us Fight-Club style as we debated loudly over the merits of the movie," says Emma Green.

"It was awesome everything ground to a halt for about five or ten minutes," says Chris Orr.

They took their debate to the web and their work garnered more than 50,000 Facebook shares.  The argument is brutal and fun.  The now decade old British film, follows nine story lines, each about some version of affection: young love, familiar companionship, ill-timed lust, and truly joyful anticipation.

Orr argues these plotlines are not only implausible but superficial, even immoral!  Far from the wholesome virtues expected this time of year.

"I think that Love Actually is only an unromantic movie but an actively anti-romantic movie," says Chris Orr.  "It's almost like a series of money shots, a mashup of first and last scenes of a variety of other romantic comedies without any of the middle part where people actually get to know each other and fall in love."

Green says love is the spirit of the season, no matter how sloppy it's expression.

"They don't have time to show all of the 4 hour conversations that eventually lead people to fall in love intellectually. It's more about that magic chemistry moment that allows people to fall into the crush-zone and I think that's a very valid and magical and wonderful thing to show," says Emma Green.

It should be noted that Love Actually got mixed reviews when it hit came out, including Orr's own scathing write up.

"When I watched it again, it was even worse than id remembered it and in particular the Kiera Knightly scene was even creepier than I remembered it," says Chris Orr.

For the record, A Christmas Story was also originally panned, but I guess you could say that criticism didn't quite stick.

And now it's an indisputable classic.

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • House GOP cancels vote on immigration bill

    House GOP cancels vote on immigration bill

    Thursday, July 31 2014 2:46 PM EDT2014-07-31 18:46:25 GMT
    Washington (CNN) -- On the last day before summer recess, dysfunction reigned in Congress.House Republicans canceled a vote on their $659 million emergency response to the border influx from Central America overwhelming immigration resources, unable to agree among themselves about what to do.More >>
    Washington (CNN) -- On the last day before summer recess, dysfunction reigned in Congress.House Republicans canceled a vote on their $659 million emergency response to the border influx from Central America overwhelming immigration resources, unable to agree among themselves about what to do.More >>
  • New Summerfield family awaits word if body found belongs to missing loved one

    New Summerfield family awaits word if body found belongs to missing loved one

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 10:22 PM EDT2014-07-31 02:22:54 GMT
    Missing person Javier JimenezMissing person Javier Jimenez
    NEW SUMMERFIELD -- Jessica Jimenez is consoled by family members after learning police have found a body just days after her father was reported missing. Javier Jimenez, 44, was last seen leaving his home in New Summerfield on the morning of July 23. More >>
    NEW SUMMERFIELD -- Jessica Jimenez is consoled by family members after learning police have found a body just days after her father was reported missing. Javier Jimenez, 44, was last seen leaving his home in New Summerfield on the morning of July 23. More >>
  • Nine Cases of Chikungunya Virus in Texas

    Nine Cases of Chikungunya Virus in Texas

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 3:58 PM EDT2014-07-30 19:58:47 GMT
    AUSTIN (KYTX)- Texas Department of State Health and Services has confirmed nine Texas cases of Chikungunya, a virus that can cause fever and severe joint pain and is transmitted by mosquitoes.More >>
    AUSTIN (KYTX)- Texas Department of State Health and Services has confirmed nine Texas cases of Chikungunya, a virus that can cause fever and severe joint pain and is transmitted by mosquitoes.More >>
Powered by WorldNow

CBS19, MYTX & KCEB
2211 ESE Loop 323
Tyler, TX 75701
Phone (903) 581-2211
Fax (903) 581-5769

Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KYTX. All Rights Reserved. Users of this site agree to the Terms of Service, Privacy Notice/Your California Privacy Rights, and Ad Choices.