Munoz life-support decision could lead to change in law - KYTX CBS 19 Tyler Longview News Weather Sports

Munoz life-support decision could lead to change in law

Posted: Updated:

FORT WORTH (CBS 11 NEWS) – Marlise Munoz died after being taken off life support Sunday morning.

After months of waiting her family is finally ready to give Marlise a proper burial, but getting to this point meant taking JPS Hospital in Fort Worth to court.

The hospital had argued that it was bound by state law and could not discontinue life-sustaining treatment from a pregnant patient.

On Friday, Judge R.H. Wallace Jr. ruled Munoz was brain dead ordered the hospital to take her off life support. Judge Wallace gave the hospital until Monday at 5 p.m. to comply with the order – giving them ample opportunity to appeal. The hospital chose not to.

"The Munoz family suffered a lot because of decision that now turns out was an error," commented Tom Mayo, a professor at the Southern Methodist University School of Law. "As someone who helped write it [law] I thought the law was pretty clear."

Yes that's right, Mayo helped write the law at the heart of the case. "I don't see where the lack of clarity is here.  I imagine we will be talking about changes for the next year," Mayo said.

There are several portions of the law that may have to be clarified. "For one thing the pregnancy clause that the hospital said they were relying on may turn out to be unconstitutional at least before the fetus reaches the stage of viability," Mayo said.

It was just before Thanksgiving when Erick Munoz found his wife Marlise, who was 14 weeks pregnant at the time, unconscious. The family says they were told the medical emergency was possibly due to a blood clot.

CBS 11 News legal expert Jerry Loftin watched the case closely and says the judge set the right precedent. "We can create Frankenstein. We have the ability to create and continue life," Loftin said. The question is – is it ‘life.' The next question is where do we draw the line?"

Loftin hypothesized the muddled legal possibilities. "Where do we go with this?" he asked. "Can you imagine everybody, that is every female, that may have died and technically be dead and someone says, ‘oh by the way, we think there may be a fetus.'"

State Representative Matt Krause said he plans to talk to lawmakers, before the next legislative session, about making clarifications to the law.

John Peter Smith Hospital is not commenting on the case.

As for the family at the center of this controversial case, Eric Munoz told the Associated Press that doctor's believed the fetus likely would have been a girl, so he decided to name the fetus after the woman carrying her. The fetus was named Nicole, which Marlise Munoz's middle name.

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Peterson's attorney responds to new allegations he injured another son

    Peterson's attorney responds to new allegations he injured another son

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 9:18 AM EDT2014-09-16 13:18:09 GMT
    HOUSTON (KHOU) -- New accusations against Adrian Peterson come from another mother who has another four-year-old son of Peterson, and also involve Peterson striking his boy as a form of discipline.Peterson's attorney Rusty Hardin responded with the following statement:The allegation of another investigation into Adrian Peterson is simply not true. This is not a new allegation, it's one that is unsubstantiated and was shopped around to authorities in two states over a year ago and nothing came...More >>
    HOUSTON (KHOU) -- New accusations against Adrian Peterson come from another mother who has another four-year-old son of Peterson, and also involve Peterson striking his boy as a form of discipline.Peterson's attorney Rusty Hardin responded with the following statement:The allegation of another investigation into Adrian Peterson is simply not true. This is not a new allegation, it's one that is unsubstantiated and was shopped around to authorities in two states over a year ago and nothing came...More >>
  • Seniors comforting VZ Co. children one blanket at a time

    Seniors comforting VZ Co. children one blanket at a time

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 8:28 AM EDT2014-09-16 12:28:41 GMT
    CANTON (KYTX) - Seniors in Canton are making a difference in the Van Zandt County community by putting their fingers to work. Ladies at Country Place Living get together every week to make blankets for abused children. More >>
    CANTON (KYTX) - Seniors in Canton are making a difference in the Van Zandt County community by putting their fingers to work. Ladies at Country Place Living get together every week to make blankets for abused children. More >>
  • Tuesday Morning Weather: Scattered showers, high 87

    Tuesday Morning Weather: Scattered showers, high 87

    East Texas (KYTX)- Good Tuesday Morning! Scattered showers and morning drizzle are possible today as a disturbance works across the state.  More >>
    East Texas (KYTX)- Good Tuesday Morning! Scattered showers and morning drizzle are possible today as a disturbance works across the state.  More >>
Powered by WorldNow

CBS19, MYTX & KCEB
2211 ESE Loop 323
Tyler, TX 75701
Phone (903) 581-2211
Fax (903) 581-5769

Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KYTX. All Rights Reserved. Users of this site agree to the Terms of Service, Privacy Notice/Your California Privacy Rights, and Ad Choices.